The ‘Yes-Men’ of Publishing: How Unchecked Compliance Breeds Author Disasters

Buckle up, folks. We’re about to dissect another aspect of the wild world of publishing, where some so-called ‘experts’ are more like yes-men in disguise, letting authors steer the ship straight into an iceberg, Titanic-style.

Imagine you’re all psyched for your first bungee jump. Adrenaline’s pumping, but you know zilch about bungee mechanics. You turn to your instructor for wisdom, and they hit you with a nod to every wild suggestion you make, including the genius idea of tying the bungee cord to your wrist to mix things up a bit. Sounds nuts? That’s exactly the kind of ride you’re in for with certain book coaches and publishers today.

These folks are supposed to be the guardians at the gates of book excellence, guiding you through the dense forest of publishing, making sure your book not only fits snugly within your genre but also knocks readers’ socks off. But nah, they’re more like sideline cheerleaders for a team that’s scoring own goals, green-lighting every half-baked idea that pops into your head, no matter how off-piste it gets.

And the prize for every idea, no matter how bonkers? A gold star and a pat on the back. It’s akin to serving up a cake on The Great British Bake Off that’s so wonky, even Paul Hollywood wouldn’t know where to start. Except, in this scenario, you’re being told it’s a masterpiece because, hey, it kinda looks like a cake if you squint.

This isn’t just unhelpful. It’s downright irresponsible. What you end up with is a book that might as well be shouting “I’m a rookie!” from the rooftops, alienating readers faster than a die-hard Motorhead fan flees a Spice Girls single on the radio.

Let’s get real: In the world of publishing, especially nonfiction, hitting your genre’s sweet spot isn’t a nice-to-have; it’s mission-critical. A book that misses its mark with the intended audience is about as useful as a ship sailing without a compass—destined to get lost in the vast ocean of content out there. You’re pushing for a passion project, but what you need is a reality check to produce something that sells, not just something that satisfies your ego.

Authors, especially the newbies, deserve coaches and publishers who have the guts to say “Nope, that ain’t it, chief” when necessary, challenging you to elevate your game and meet the high standards your work deserves. It’s about finding that sweet equilibrium between your unique voice and the expectations of your readers, ensuring your book isn’t just professional and polished but also hits the right notes with the audience.

This balanced approach doesn’t just pay lip service to readers. It paves your path to lasting success. Sure, cutting corners might seem like a shortcut now, but the real treasure lies in investing in quality, crafting a book that builds your credibility, earns reader trust, and, yes, rings the cash register in the long run.

If you need IMPARTIAL FREE nonfiction advice, check out my online benchmarks. They tell you straight.

Begin your book with confidence: How Market-Ready is Your Book Idea?

Publish your book with confidence: Is Your Final Draft Publishing Ready?

Revive your book with confidence: Take Your Book From Hidden Gem to Headliner!

Tell your friends about these. Let’s head the shysters off at the pass, eh?

Scroll to Top